So later this month, Matt’s Cigar Journal will be turning 5 years old. Five years in Internet age is like 50 in human years. Sites come and go virtually every second on the web, so for me to have kept this thing going for 5 years feels like an accomplishment of sorts for me. A big anniversary like this deserves to be celebrated so I am going to review a special cigar for that day and I am going to look to my readers to help me decide what it will be. Please take a moment to answer the poll question and let me know which of these cigars you think is most appropriate for Matt’s Cigar Journal’s 5 Year Anniversary Review. You can leave comments on this post if you’d like to elaborate on your vote. I only possess one of each of the cigars listed in this poll so it will be a special event when I smoke it. The review will be posted on June 23rd, the day my blog turns 5.
I will shut down this poll on June 16th and announce my selection.





[...] help him decide which cigar to fire in celebration of the blog’s 5 year anniversary. Toast it here. Back to Top Filed In: Toast of the WeekTags: Camacho LegendArio, cigar, Cigar Review, [...]
Dude, it is not even close, go with the SW Maduro…you will be sorry if you don’t
Can I sport one of those “I Voted” buttons now?
BTW: I’ll gladly take any one of those lousy runners-up off your hands! Get rid of those embarrassing losers, willya!
I saw the Cohiba Reserva in a shop in Madrid but didn’t pull the trigger… It sure must be a good smoke!
I believe that the cohiba is actually from the 03 Reserva Selectione as 06 was the PSD4 Reserva.
Could be. Was a gift from a friend in Denmark who happens to be a Habanos dealer. It came from a box of Cohiba Reservas that contained several different sizes. The date I listed was from the year he gave it to me.